â€œWe danced but we were more just talking,â€ Herndon revealed of their first meeting. â€œThere was definitely an attraction but nothing really happened that night.â€
Phelps and Herndon hung out again and shared their first kiss.
He did not want to part when it was time for him to leave Cabo, so he invited her to the Bahamas where sparks ignited.
â€œWe were holding hands and he was putting his arm around meâ€¦heâ€™s really caring and affectionate. He would kiss me in front of his friends. He was treating me like I was his girl,â€ Sarah gushed.